New Hope Network

Natural Products Expo:
East
West
New Product Launch Pad
New Hope

Archive of the Sports Nutrition Category

Sports Illustrated Slams Supplements and DSHEA

In a May 18 Sports Illustrated cover feature titled “Supplements: The Dangerous Obsession with Improved Performance,” David Epstein and George Dohrmann do their best to deliver a knock-out punch to the sports supplement industry and the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA), which the writers say is the basic reason the sports supplement industry has become “a Pandora’s Box of false claims, untested products and bogus science.”

The piece brings up numerous examples of professional players being punished for using supplements spiked with banned substances, delves into the recent Hydroxycut recall and rehashes the dark days of ephedra. It also features several sports supplement retailers and product developers who reap riches from selling and concocting stimulant-filled products that can be sold “with no proof of effectiveness or safety, and without approval from the FDA.” The story goes on to talk about about how GNC salespeople are paid commission by sports supplement manufacturers to push their products on “unsuspecting customers” who “are sometimes steered to a supplement that is inappropriate for their needs.” It ends with discussion of sports supplement companies manipulating the findings from clinical research or rigging the studies altogether. Taken as a whole, the articles paints a grim portrait of a rogue sports supplement industry that the writers say Nutrition Business Journal research estimates generated nearly $20 billion in U.S. sales in 2007.

The trouble is, the writers use carefully chosen examples to tell only one side of the story—and they misleadingly cite NBJ research to create a picture of an industry that appears much larger than it actually is. In 2007, U.S. sales of sports supplement products totaled $2.5 billion, while the entire U.S. sports nutrition & weight-loss (SNWL) sector—which includes sports supplements, weight-loss pills, meal-replacement supplements, low-carb foods, nutrition bars, and sports & energy drinks—generated just under $20 billion in sales in 2007. Yes, sales of sports supplements have been growing but they still constitute a relatively small piece of the overall SNWL market—and this certainly was not made clear in the way Sports Illustrated cited our research.

Exposés such as the Sports Illustrated article are, unfortunately, not new for the dietary supplement industry, and they will continue as long as there are examples of products containing banned substances, of researching being manipulated, of false or misleading claims, or of people becoming sick after using a supplement—even if these instances do not reflect the overall nature of the supplement industry at large.

The good news is that now the supplement industry has good manufacturing practices (GMPs) and the serious adverse event reporting (SAER) system to ensure supplement product quality and demonstrate the safety of dietary supplements. We also have organizations such as the Council for Responsible Nutrition, the Natural Products Association and NSF International to ably communicate the positive, responsible side of the supplement industry and help ensure the safety and quality of supplement products. But, in this day and age, the industry is likely to need more than that if it wants to protect its reputation and current regulatory structure. To weather the current media storm, all supplement companies are going to need to help defend the industry by strictly adhering to GMPs and DSHEA, by speaking out against potentially damaging products and companies, and by only doing business with those companies whose practices and ideals they support.


Related links:

How Worrisome is the Hydroxycut Recall for the Dietary Supplement Industry?

Industry Making Strides in Improving Tarnished Image of Weight-Loss Supplements

New Supplement Regulations Most Important for Industry Since Passage of DSHEA

Q&A With Joseph Fortunato, Chief Executive Officer of GNC

NBJ had the opportunity to speak with GNC Chief Executive Officer Joe Fortunato on March 23 regarding the company’s impressive 2008 performance. GNC posted sales growth of 6.7% for the year, with same-store sales growth of 2.7%. Perhaps more impressive were the the revenue gains in the fourth quarter across all divisions, even in the midst of a severe consumer spending downturn. In our conversation, Fortunato talks about some of the factors that contributed to GNC’s success in 2008, as well as the the company’s outlook for 2009 and beyond.

NBJ: What were some of the main growth drivers in Q4, and for the entire year?

Joe Fortunato: We had a really strong vitamin business throughout the year and we had a reasonably strong sports business throughout the year. Our sports business really accelerated in our own brand. Our Pro Performance brand grew in strong double digits and it has started out this year extremely well. At one point [the Pro Performance product line] was more of a house brand. Today, we’ve accelerated the brand through science and innovation and new product introductions to be anywhere from an entry level brand to up to a premium brand. That brand equity and the innovation we’ve brought to the brand is really starting to pay off.

NBJ: Your manufacturing/wholesale division was up almost 14% in Q4, what led to that double digit growth?

JF: If you remember back to the [Royal Numico N.V.] days, we cut out almost all contract manufacturing. That was a Numico decision and that was a very, very bad decision on their part. At one point, without the Rexall business, we were as low as $14 million in contract manufacturing business. Today we’re doing over $125 million in contract manufacturing business. So that’s not only accelerating, but we’ve made a very pointed effort strategically to go after more contract manufacturing to get better absorption in our manufacturing facility. We’ve not only been able to get more contract manufacturing business since 2003-2004 and grow it steadily every year; we’ve also enhanced the margins coming out of that business.

NBJ: Why was it a bad decision by Numico to cut contract manufacturing?

There are two reasons. First of all, if you don’t make it, somebody else will make it for them. Second, if you have the capacity, you may as well try to absorb it. It helps control the costs of the GNC brand by absorbing that capacity.

NBJ: Same-store sales continued to improve despite a weakening economy, what factored into that growth? We’ve always heard that athletes are more brand/product loyal in their purchasing habits than many other market segments; do you think that’s true? How does that tie in with GNC’s 2008 performance?

JF: If you look back over history, we have developed tremendous brand loyalty at GNC. In the vitamin business, I think the brand loyalty is second to none. With Pro Performance developing the way it has, the brand loyalty in the sports business is continuing to accelerate. So the answer to that would be that the brand–the recognition of the brand, the loyalty from consumers and the integrity that the brand represents–has really really been the foothold that GNC has capitalized on over the past couple of years. We continue to differentiate our brand. Our mantra three to four years ago was to differentiate. The business was becoming too commoditized. I felt the way to win the game was to differentiate GNC from the rest of the field. Science and innovation is one of the ways we have done that.

NBJ: How have internet sales contributed to GNC’s business?

JF: Our web business grew about 28% in 2008. It’s growing very fast again in 2009. We plan to continue to accelerate the website and we are investing about $5 million over the next few years to redevelop the whole thing. The functionality will be redone. It will have an interactive feel to it. They’ll also be some social networking components within the next 12-18 months. Obviously we are looking at ways to get more aggressive on the web to be competitive with some of our major web competitors.

NBJ: What percentage of GNC’s business is done on the internet?

JF: Web sales are very small component, less than 3%. I think our web business in the next 3 years will be $125 million. We’ve just touched the surface there, it wasn’t a priority early on, but we’ve made it more of a priority.

NBJ: Has the economic recession helped GNC’s private label [Pro Performance brand]? NBJ has seen examples of consumers trading down to private label in the foods market to maximize value.

JF: Even with our entry level products, quality is always a strength of ours. We’ve been very conscientious of what’s going on in the economy, so what we’ve done is allowed for a good price point where people come in and they want to try things. Then, we’ve positioned the consumers into more complex premium formulations as they become acclimated with the use of supplements. The mentality of the consumer is that they always want the best. Once you get them involved in the business, that’s more price point oriented, after that it’s all about the brands and the trust and the integrity and offering the best products in the marketplace. That’s how we play our retail business.

NBJ: How has the recession impacted the company?

JF: I couldn’t sit here and say we haven’t been impacted. We’ve been conscious of the potential impact the economy could have on us. I think we’ve been more promotional because of that. We went into January and February with some very strong promotions. We are very sensitive to pricing with our consumers. We’ve absorbed raw material price increases rather than passing them along to our customers. To put a finger on how much we’ve been affected is hard to do; everybody has been affected a little bit. One thing that helps out is that this industry is less discretionary than a lot of other industries.

NBJ: What is your outlook for the rest of 2009 and 2010? You’ve weathered the economic storm pretty well; do you see more success down the road?

JF: First of all, I couldn’t be more pleased with how we performed during this economic downturn. The exciting part is that we still have tremendous opportunities ahead of us. We have more initiatives than we can handle. We are one of the few businesses that can be more selective about how we grow this business moving forward–what categories we’ll focus on more effectively, how we position our business more effectively, there are just numerous, numerous opportunities.

We’ve invested heavily in the business–we’ve put in new point of sale registry systems that have cost us somewhere in the range of $20 million. So we’ve got better training and selling tools in the stores. We have higher end sophistication in regards to technology, better communication with our employees, better cross-selling opportunities that are suggested on register systems–all things that can help advance interaction with employees and consumers. We also invested $5 million in the web business, we’ve invested a couple million dollars in WebMD for relationship over a two and a half year period, we’ve invested in a new creative advertising agency in addition to our normal marketing. That has paid off tremendously. The payoff on our advertising is the best in the 20 years I’ve been here.

The mindset here has been to over-deliver, maintain a strong performance during this downturned economy and think logically about how most effectively to do that. I think we’ve managed that very well. Then the other component has been to start investing in the business to give us upside potential for the future. We’ve been fortunate enough to do both; we’ve hit the performance numbers and beat them and we’ve invested in the business and we will continue to invest in 2009 to position ourselves in 2010, so I think we’re in a very good position right now.


Related Links:

CRN: Supplements Are Still a Priority for Consumers, Despite Slumping Economy

Health Clubs and Gyms Work to Bulk Up on Sports Supplement Sales

Web Pumps Up Sales of Sports Supplements

Weight loss pill sales down, bars flat, sports supplements up….what’s going on with the U.S. Sports Nutrition & Weight Loss Market?

Did you know that weight loss pill sales only make up 8% of the total U.S. sports nutrition & weight loss market? Did you know the nutrition bar market is larger than the total low-carb foods market? If not, join NBJ editorial director Patrick Rea and Katia Fowler, Director of Communication and former editor of NBJ as they present the 2007/2008 Sports Nutrition & Weight Loss Market Overview Webseminar.

In this NBJ webseminar, we will answer:


Weight Loss

Does Fucoxanthin have the potential to replace ephedra as the weight-loss market king?

How long will alli suppress U.S. weight loss supplement sales growth?

What will be the best sales channel to sell your new (or old) weight-loss product through over the next 5 years?

Where does the GSK petition stand and what are the next steps for the nutrition industry?

Have the AERs shown any prevalence of stimulant complaints?

What’s going on in low-carb? Will it ever disappear?


Sports Nutrition

Why has the energy drink market’s growth slowed?

Will any sports beverage brand successfully challenge Gatorade?

Did the nutrition bar market continue to rebound in 2007? Which bar brands grew, which brands faltered, and why?

What brands and markets are behind the 8.4% growth in the sports nutrition supplement market in 2007?

What channels should sports nutrition brands shy away from to ensure future success?

What alternative channels for sports nutrition products retain potential for future growth and expansion?

Upcoming Sports Nutrition & Weight Loss Market Web Seminar

Nutrition Business Journal will host a live web seminar to review the six segments of the $18.26-billion U.S. Sports Nutrition and Weight Loss market and their significance to the $94-billion U.S. nutrition industry. The web seminar will be held on Thursday, September 25, 2008 at 11-12:30 pm Mountain Time. The presentation will include the NBJ editorial team and industry experts.

Share the knowledge! A registration fee of only $495 allows up to six login points for you and your colleagues. Participants will be provided access to a website for the live presentation.

Pivotal issues to be discussed include:

• Erratic ingredient supply markets

New regulatory developments

• The impact of acquisitions on legacy brands

• Mergers & acquisitions in the sports nutrition & weight loss market space

Tuning in gets you:

• A full analysis of the six SNWL categories with recent growth and forecasts through 2016

• Overviews on changing shares in weight-loss pills and meal replacements

• Updates on the explosive energy drink market and sports drinks performance

• Discussion of marketing tactics, regulations, claims, M&As, science and consumers

• Reporting on new growth sub-categories and niche products that are sustaining growth for the greater sports nutrition & weight loss market

Wanted: Sports Nutrition & Weight Loss Companies

Nutrition Business Journal would like you to participate in our 2008 Sports Nutrition & Weight Loss Manufacturer/Marketer Survey. Data collected in the survey will be used in NBJ’s September 2008 Sports Nutrition & Weight Loss issue. The survey should take you no more than 5 minutes. As a thank you for participating, you will receive a free copy of the survey results once the research has been completed. Any comments, questions or concerns should be directed to NBJ Research Manager Jason Phillips at 303.998.9249.


-Patrick